We love it when our readers want to share their voices, which is why we are thrilled to invite today’s guest poster back for a second time. Abby is a long-time reader of Just.Be.Enough. and first shared her story of what makes her special. Abby writes mostly about kids, motherhood, and writing. Her story today was inspired by Angela’s post about choosing to live near her family.
——
When I was growing up in New England, my small family — mom, dad, two kids — did not live close to any extended family. One set of grandparents was in California, the other in Florida, with various cousins, aunts, and uncles scattered around the rest of the country. We saw them maybe once, twice a year, tops.
My mom says I always wished for a big, close-knit family like that of my best friend, Lisa, who had lots of relatives in town and always had a substantial cheering section in the audience at school plays and dance recitals.
When it came time to apply to college, my parents encouraged me to look at schools all over the country. Staying close to home was never a consideration. I chose a college a couple hours away, then moved 300 miles away after graduation.
As fate would have it, I met a guy who came from a large family and hailed from New England, too, a mere 90 minutes from where I grew up. We fell in love, got married, and enjoyed the ease of visiting two sets of parents in a single trip.
Then we had kids.
Suddenly, the parents who had said, “Sure, apply to college in California! Go off to France for semester! Bon voyage!” changed their tune. “When are you coming home again? Thanksgiving? Christmas? Why do you have to live so far away?!” And of course there was another set of eager grandparents to consider, too.
But as we added another child to our brood and they both started school, it got more difficult and expensive to travel. We’ve endured rescheduled flights, snowstorms, holiday traffic, ear infections on airplanes, sleepless nights in a portable crib. After one particularly grueling nine-hour drive home one Thanksgiving weekend, I swore: Never again. Relatives come visit us from time to time, but it’s not the same as living in the same town.
My husband and I have talked about “moving back home.” But the fact is, this is our home now. We’ve lived in our current city longer than we lived in our hometowns. Our work is here, our friends are here, our kids’ schools are here. We have built lives here, full of great friends and neighbors, trusted babysitters, people who feel like family. We like the city where we live, the place we chose to raise our family.
But even though I chose this life, I sometimes feel sorry for myself. I’ll see neighbors getting together with their families on a Sunday, cousins playing together at cookouts, friends dropping the kids off for a sleepover at Grandma’s. Whereas we have to hire a sitter for every date night, teacher meeting, doctor’s appointment, even to do projects around the house without kids underfoot. Once I even got a sitter on a Sunday afternoon just so my husband could watch football in peace and I could go shopping by myself. I have missed countless school events because I can’t be in two places at once.
In some ways, living closer to family would be easier. Easier on us, our marriage, our budget, our kids’ relationship with their grandparents. But, like most things in life, it’s not that easy. And of course as we all know, geographic proximity is not a guarantee of closeness.
Some part of me will always wonder what it would be like to live in the same city as my extended family. But I also know that I am blessed to have my own little family — mom, dad, two kids — and the life we’ve built for ourselves here, surrounded by friends and loved ones of our own choosing.








[...] be different if I had chosen to live near my extended family? Click on over to Just.Be.Enough to read my post. Do you live near your family? Or far away? What’s the better scenario? I’d love to [...]
Very well done. Just remember family doesn’t always have to be about blood.
Corey Feldman recently posted..I think my head is going to explode
Good point, Corey. I agree.
Abby recently posted..When You Live Far Away from Family
It is hard and living with family right there can also be straining on marriage etc as in laws usually have their own ideas.
Jess recently posted..Thinking Thursday
I’ve heard that from friends who live near family, too. I know not everyone has a smooth relationship with their in-laws!
Abby recently posted..When You Live Far Away from Family
I’m a British expat living in the Netherlands and can vouch that geographical proximity does not mean closeness. The majority of my inlaws are half an hour away but have never showed any interest in my kids. My kids have a better relationship with family in England & the US. It’s not ideal being away from family but I guess we all just make the best of how it is. For the first few years I was here, people in England asked when I’d be coming home…… they don’t ask anymore because they know I am home!!!!
Home is where my husband and kids are.
Amanda recently posted..Christmas Gifts Crafted by Creative Expats: La Petite Lulu’s Soft Toys
“Home is where my husband and kids are.” Love that, Amanda!
Abby recently posted..When You Live Far Away from Family
I’ve lived away from family for more than 30 years, and it’s worked out well because it’s kept me out of family dramas. Both of my stepkids have chosen to live in different cities as well, and we’re fine with that. Will I change when I’m a grandma? Don’t know that yet!
One change that has happened recently is that my parents need more assistance. This year I’ve made arrangements to make an extra trip, and I am coordinating with my sister, who lives near them, to make sure that she’s not carrying the bulk of the load. It will be interesting to see how this challenge unfolds as my parents get less independent.
We’re more fortunate than most in that we have both time and financial flexibility, so that we can travel as much as we want or need to. I think it’s a lot tougher for families who don’t have that.
Nadine Feldman recently posted..Friday Fun: A Photo Collage
That is certainly true, Nadine. Aging parents add a whole new element to the living-away-from-home situation. It’s great that you have a sibling who will share the load.
Abby recently posted..When You Live Far Away from Family
Abby, this post inspired me to write my own post on this topic…… thank you for planting a seed
http://lifewithadoublebuggy.blogspot.nl/2012/11/choosing-to-live-away-from-family.html
Amanda recently posted..Choosing to Live Away from Family
Great! Off to read it now…
Abby recently posted..When You Live Far Away from Family
As a military wife and mom, I haven’t had many chances to live near my family. And I definitely know the hardship of traveling with kids to visit relatives. But I also feel like my kids get the best of both worlds because they get to see new places and go on adventures that they probably would never have if we didn’t live a highly mobile lifestyle. Right now we’re preparing for a 3-year assignment to Sweden. It’s a hoot hearing my 2 year old practice asking for her morning “meeyelk” in Swedish.

Heidi Smith Luedtke recently posted..10 Things I Know Right Now
I so completely get this. As long as I’ve lived in Ireland (6 years now), I have wanted to move back home, to be part of those weekend barbecues and Saturday trips to Target with my sister and such. As the years go by, I feel more and more settled here. I’m not sure if I am happy about that or not. What am I missing out on? What are my kids missing out on? I still don’t have the answer, but luckily I’m usually to busy to ruminate about it:)
[...] office colleagues I see daily. My husband commutes and works long hours. My extended family lives far away. So my happiness has increased a bazillion percent by having friends in the neighborhood. Luckily, [...]